He Asked For A Lift To A Village That Was Demolished In 1965
68% BELIEVED
CASE FILE #362
FILED: May 8, 2026
CLASSIFICATION: Creepy Strangers Stories
WITNESS ON RECORD: BarracksVin
JURY OF 258 READERS HEARD THIS CASE: 176 believed it, 35 had doubts, 47 weren't buying it.
He was standing where the lane meets the main road, which is a stupid place to stand, and he had a bag on his shoulder, and it was February and it was dark at five.
He asked for a lift to Thornhaugh.
There is no Thornhaugh. There has not been a Thornhaugh since 1965, when they flooded the valley and made the reservoir, and my grandmother, who was born there, used to talk about the church tower being visible in a dry summer.
I said, "There's no Thornhaugh, mate."
He said, pleasantly, "Then take me as far as the crossroads and I'll walk."
I want to tell you why I let him in. I let him in because he was completely, boringly normal. Fifties. A donkey jacket. A canvas bag. A tired man at the end of a shift. If he had been strange, I would have driven on.
He gave me directions. He said, "Left at the top, then the second right, past the chapel."
There is no chapel. There is a bend and a bus shelter.
He asked for a lift to Thornhaugh.
There is no Thornhaugh. There has not been a Thornhaugh since 1965, when they flooded the valley and made the reservoir, and my grandmother, who was born there, used to talk about the church tower being visible in a dry summer.
I said, "There's no Thornhaugh, mate."
He said, pleasantly, "Then take me as far as the crossroads and I'll walk."
I want to tell you why I let him in. I let him in because he was completely, boringly normal. Fifties. A donkey jacket. A canvas bag. A tired man at the end of a shift. If he had been strange, I would have driven on.
He gave me directions. He said, "Left at the top, then the second right, past the chapel."
There is no chapel. There is a bend and a bus shelter.
THIS EXCERPT ENDS HERE. The remaining 170 words of the testimony — and the reader jury — are on file at:
Read the full case & cast your verdict
https://www.swearithappened.com/creepy-stranger-stories/he-asked-for-a-lift-to-a-village-that-was-demolished-in-1965-362/
Votes on record: 176 believed · 35 unsure · 47 didn't · 68% of readers believe this story