The Hitchhiker I Did Not Pick Up Was Standing At The Cemetery Gate In The Morning
72% BELIEVED
CASE FILE #369
FILED: May 15, 2026
CLASSIFICATION: Ghost Stories
WITNESS ON RECORD: DispatchOwen
JURY OF 269 READERS HEARD THIS CASE: 194 believed it, 32 had doubts, 43 weren't buying it.
I did not pick him up because it was midnight and I am a woman on my own and I have a mother who raised me properly.
He was standing at the junction by the old mill. Long coat. Canvas bag over the shoulder. He raised a hand — not a thumb, a hand, flat, like a man greeting a neighbour.
I drove past and I felt bad about it for about six miles, which is the correct amount of time to feel bad about doing the sensible thing.
The next morning I drove out to the cemetery, because it was my father's anniversary and because I take him a plant that he would have said was a waste of money.
He was standing at the cemetery gate. Same coat, same bag.
Twelve miles from the junction. On foot, at night, in the rain, that is not impossible — it is four or five hours — and I want to be fair to reality here.
I stopped. I do not know why. I stopped and I put the window down and I said, "Did you walk?"
And he said — and this is the first sentence, and he said it as if we were continuing a conversation — "You couldn't have stopped last night. It wasn't the night for it."
He was standing at the junction by the old mill. Long coat. Canvas bag over the shoulder. He raised a hand — not a thumb, a hand, flat, like a man greeting a neighbour.
I drove past and I felt bad about it for about six miles, which is the correct amount of time to feel bad about doing the sensible thing.
The next morning I drove out to the cemetery, because it was my father's anniversary and because I take him a plant that he would have said was a waste of money.
He was standing at the cemetery gate. Same coat, same bag.
Twelve miles from the junction. On foot, at night, in the rain, that is not impossible — it is four or five hours — and I want to be fair to reality here.
I stopped. I do not know why. I stopped and I put the window down and I said, "Did you walk?"
And he said — and this is the first sentence, and he said it as if we were continuing a conversation — "You couldn't have stopped last night. It wasn't the night for it."
THIS EXCERPT ENDS HERE. The remaining 161 words of the testimony — and the reader jury — are on file at:
Read the full case & cast your verdict
https://www.swearithappened.com/ghost-stories/the-hitchhiker-i-did-not-pick-up-was-standing-at-the-cemetery-gate-in-the-morning-369/
Votes on record: 194 believed · 32 unsure · 43 didn't · 72% of readers believe this story