The Line Across Her Neck And The Train That Was Never Ours
54% BELIEVED
CASE FILE #433
FILED: May 3, 2026
CLASSIFICATION: Reincarnation Stories
WITNESS ON RECORD: GreyhoundJoe
JURY OF 191 READERS HEARD THIS CASE: 104 believed it, 36 had doubts, 51 weren't buying it.
My daughter was born with a faint reddish band that goes most of the way around her neck, low, like the shadow of a collar. The doctors had a long word for it and said it would likely fade. It has faded, mostly. You have to know it is there to see it now. But she has always known it is there.
She has been afraid of level crossings since before she could explain why. The barriers, the lights, the bell, the long low shape of a train coming through. She does not scream. She goes rigid and grips my hand and will not breathe until it has passed. Other loud things do not bother her. Fireworks, thunder, the dog next door, none of it. Only the crossing.
When she was old enough to put words together she started telling me about a platform. A cold platform, early, with frost on the edge of it, and too many people, and a case that was too heavy so she had to keep putting it down. She told me she was in a hurry. She told me she was going to see someone and she was late and the platform was crowded and someone was pushing to the front.
She said her name was Margaret. She said it firmly, the way you correct someone. She said, before I was your girl I was Margaret and I wore a grey coat with a belt. She was so young when she said this. She had never met a Margaret. It is not a name in our family, not a name from her stories or her programmes, not a name I had ever said in front of her.
One night she told me the rest and it frightened me so much I wrote it down, word for word, so I would not soften it later in my memory. She said the case slipped and she bent to get it and she was too close to the edge and the crowd moved and there was a sound and then everything was very fast and then very slow and then she was warm. She put her hand to the faint band on her neck when she said the fast part. She said, it happened here, and then I came to you.
She has been afraid of level crossings since before she could explain why. The barriers, the lights, the bell, the long low shape of a train coming through. She does not scream. She goes rigid and grips my hand and will not breathe until it has passed. Other loud things do not bother her. Fireworks, thunder, the dog next door, none of it. Only the crossing.
When she was old enough to put words together she started telling me about a platform. A cold platform, early, with frost on the edge of it, and too many people, and a case that was too heavy so she had to keep putting it down. She told me she was in a hurry. She told me she was going to see someone and she was late and the platform was crowded and someone was pushing to the front.
She said her name was Margaret. She said it firmly, the way you correct someone. She said, before I was your girl I was Margaret and I wore a grey coat with a belt. She was so young when she said this. She had never met a Margaret. It is not a name in our family, not a name from her stories or her programmes, not a name I had ever said in front of her.
One night she told me the rest and it frightened me so much I wrote it down, word for word, so I would not soften it later in my memory. She said the case slipped and she bent to get it and she was too close to the edge and the crowd moved and there was a sound and then everything was very fast and then very slow and then she was warm. She put her hand to the faint band on her neck when she said the fast part. She said, it happened here, and then I came to you.
THIS EXCERPT ENDS HERE. The remaining 303 words of the testimony — and the reader jury — are on file at:
Read the full case & cast your verdict
https://www.swearithappened.com/reincarnation-stories/the-line-across-her-neck-and-the-train-that-was-never-ours-433/
Votes on record: 104 believed · 36 unsure · 51 didn't · 54% of readers believe this story