The Thing In The Orchard Had Knees That Bent The Wrong Way
62% BELIEVED
CASE FILE #297
FILED: Mar 4, 2026
CLASSIFICATION: Alien Stories
WITNESS ON RECORD: leobro
JURY OF 133 READERS HEARD THIS CASE: 83 believed it, 24 had doubts, 26 weren't buying it.
Our orchard is nine trees and a fence. In September the ground goes yellow with windfalls and the wasps get drunk and my mother pays me to rake.
I went out at dusk with a torch because I had left the rake against the fence and my mother has strong opinions about tools left out in dew.
There was a figure between the fourth and fifth tree, and my first thought — I want to be honest about my first thought — was that it was a heron. Because of the way it stood. Very still, weight on one side, head lowered like something that fishes for a living.
But herons are not five and a half feet tall, and they do not have arms.
It was collecting apples. It would bend, and the bend happened at the wrong point, high up, so that the lower leg swung forward instead of back, and it would pick up one apple, turn it, and set it down again. Not eat it. Set it down. Then take another. It did this maybe six times while I stood there with a torch I had not switched on, because switching it on felt like knocking on a door I did not want opened.
I went out at dusk with a torch because I had left the rake against the fence and my mother has strong opinions about tools left out in dew.
There was a figure between the fourth and fifth tree, and my first thought — I want to be honest about my first thought — was that it was a heron. Because of the way it stood. Very still, weight on one side, head lowered like something that fishes for a living.
But herons are not five and a half feet tall, and they do not have arms.
It was collecting apples. It would bend, and the bend happened at the wrong point, high up, so that the lower leg swung forward instead of back, and it would pick up one apple, turn it, and set it down again. Not eat it. Set it down. Then take another. It did this maybe six times while I stood there with a torch I had not switched on, because switching it on felt like knocking on a door I did not want opened.
THIS EXCERPT ENDS HERE. The remaining 189 words of the testimony — and the reader jury — are on file at:
Read the full case & cast your verdict
https://www.swearithappened.com/alien-stories/the-thing-in-the-orchard-had-knees-that-bent-the-wrong-way-297/
Votes on record: 83 believed · 24 unsure · 26 didn't · 62% of readers believe this story