The Toll Booth Regular Who Died in 1994
93% BELIEVED
CASE FILE #107
FILED: Mar 26, 2026
CLASSIFICATION: Night Shift Stories
WITNESS ON RECORD: SaltmarshTed
JURY OF 96 READERS HEARD THIS CASE: 89 believed it, 4 had doubts, 3 weren't buying it.
The training for graveyard toll work is thin, so the real handover happens in the notes previous booth workers leave taped inside the cabinet. Most are practical — which card reader is temperamental, where the good torch is. One, in faded biro, said only: '2:15, lane 4, cash, blue car, DON'T KEEP THE COIN. Just wave him on. He's alright.'
I assumed a prank until my fourth night, when at 2:15 a car came through lane four — a boxy blue saloon, a model I couldn't place and later identified as something discontinued in the early nineties — and a man in his sixties wound down the window and held out exact change, coins warm and ordinary in my palm. He nodded, said 'goodnight, then,' and drove on. Pleasant. Unremarkable, except for the strangeness that lane four's automatic barrier didn't trigger the vehicle sensor, and my transaction log showed no vehicle for that timestamp — but the coins were real, in my hand, in the drawer.
He came most nights, always 2:15, always lane four, always the exact toll — which is itself impossible, because the toll has changed twice since the nineties, and he always paid the CURRENT amount, in current coins, from a car that predated both increases.
I assumed a prank until my fourth night, when at 2:15 a car came through lane four — a boxy blue saloon, a model I couldn't place and later identified as something discontinued in the early nineties — and a man in his sixties wound down the window and held out exact change, coins warm and ordinary in my palm. He nodded, said 'goodnight, then,' and drove on. Pleasant. Unremarkable, except for the strangeness that lane four's automatic barrier didn't trigger the vehicle sensor, and my transaction log showed no vehicle for that timestamp — but the coins were real, in my hand, in the drawer.
He came most nights, always 2:15, always lane four, always the exact toll — which is itself impossible, because the toll has changed twice since the nineties, and he always paid the CURRENT amount, in current coins, from a car that predated both increases.
THIS EXCERPT ENDS HERE. The remaining 153 words of the testimony — and the reader jury — are on file at:
Read the full case & cast your verdict
https://www.swearithappened.com/night-shift-stories/the-toll-booth-regular-who-died-in-1994-107/
Votes on record: 89 believed · 4 unsure · 3 didn't · 93% of readers believe this story