First Time in Lisbon, Except It Wasn't
68% BELIEVED
CASE FILE #33
FILED: Mar 14, 2026
CLASSIFICATION: Deja Vu Stories
WITNESS ON RECORD: GreyhoundJoe
JURY OF 114 READERS HEARD THIS CASE: 77 believed it, 21 had doubts, 16 weren't buying it.
Neither of us had been to Lisbon. No family ties, no previous trips, and I had done none of the planning — my wife booked everything, and I deliberately avoid maps on holiday.
Day two, we came out of a tram stop into the Alfama, that famous tangle where every guide warns you will get lost, and my feet turned left with complete authority. My wife had the map app open; I was suddenly walking like a man late for work. She trotted behind, amused. 'Where are you going?' 'There is a fountain with a cracked basin around this corner,' I said — not guessing, reporting. There was.
It kept happening. I knew the alley that looked like a dead end but dog-legged through an arch. I knew which staircase smelled of oranges — I said 'oranges' on the way in, and there was a tree in the courtyard at the top. Then I stopped, mid-street, and said, 'Two more corners and there is a bakery, tiny, blue-tiled, and the woman there is deaf and you point at what you want.' Two corners. Blue tiles the colour of old dishes. Behind the counter, an elderly woman who watched our mouths and pointed back at the pastries, smiling the smile of someone who has won this game for fifty years.
Day two, we came out of a tram stop into the Alfama, that famous tangle where every guide warns you will get lost, and my feet turned left with complete authority. My wife had the map app open; I was suddenly walking like a man late for work. She trotted behind, amused. 'Where are you going?' 'There is a fountain with a cracked basin around this corner,' I said — not guessing, reporting. There was.
It kept happening. I knew the alley that looked like a dead end but dog-legged through an arch. I knew which staircase smelled of oranges — I said 'oranges' on the way in, and there was a tree in the courtyard at the top. Then I stopped, mid-street, and said, 'Two more corners and there is a bakery, tiny, blue-tiled, and the woman there is deaf and you point at what you want.' Two corners. Blue tiles the colour of old dishes. Behind the counter, an elderly woman who watched our mouths and pointed back at the pastries, smiling the smile of someone who has won this game for fifty years.
THIS EXCERPT ENDS HERE. The remaining 108 words of the testimony — and the reader jury — are on file at:
Read the full case & cast your verdict
https://www.swearithappened.com/deja-vu-stories/first-time-in-lisbon-except-it-wasn-t-33/
Votes on record: 77 believed · 21 unsure · 16 didn't · 68% of readers believe this story