My Landlord Had a Key and Used It When We Were Out
73% BELIEVED
CASE FILE #283
FILED: Mar 6, 2026
CLASSIFICATION: Rental Nightmares Stories
WITNESS ON RECORD: ColdChapelKate
JURY OF 388 READERS HEARD THIS CASE: 285 believed it, 53 had doubts, 50 weren't buying it.
We rented the ground floor of a house, and from the first month something was off. Small things. A chair not quite where we left it. A cupboard door open we were sure we had closed. My mail opened and resealed clumsily. A faint smell of a cologne neither of us wore, hanging in the living room some evenings when we got home from work.
We told ourselves we were imagining it, or being forgetful, the way you do, until the day my partner came home early with a migraine and heard someone moving around inside our locked flat, and by the time she got the door open, the back door was just clicking shut and no one was there. That was the day we bought a small camera and hid it on a shelf facing the living room.
What we caught over the next two weeks made my skin crawl. Our landlord, who lived upstairs, let himself in with his key twice a week, always during our work hours. He did not fix anything. He did not have a reason. He would come in, walk slowly through the flat, and sit down in our living room, in our chair, for twenty minutes or more, just sitting, sometimes with his eyes closed. He went through the stack of our mail on the table, reading it, opening some of it. He opened our fridge and looked in it. And once, on the recording that ended it for us, he walked into our bedroom, and lay down on our made bed, on top of the covers, on my partner's side, for several minutes, before getting up, smoothing the spread, and letting himself back out.
We told ourselves we were imagining it, or being forgetful, the way you do, until the day my partner came home early with a migraine and heard someone moving around inside our locked flat, and by the time she got the door open, the back door was just clicking shut and no one was there. That was the day we bought a small camera and hid it on a shelf facing the living room.
What we caught over the next two weeks made my skin crawl. Our landlord, who lived upstairs, let himself in with his key twice a week, always during our work hours. He did not fix anything. He did not have a reason. He would come in, walk slowly through the flat, and sit down in our living room, in our chair, for twenty minutes or more, just sitting, sometimes with his eyes closed. He went through the stack of our mail on the table, reading it, opening some of it. He opened our fridge and looked in it. And once, on the recording that ended it for us, he walked into our bedroom, and lay down on our made bed, on top of the covers, on my partner's side, for several minutes, before getting up, smoothing the spread, and letting himself back out.
THIS EXCERPT ENDS HERE. The remaining 112 words of the testimony — and the reader jury — are on file at:
Read the full case & cast your verdict
https://www.swearithappened.com/rental-nightmare-stories/my-landlord-had-a-key-and-used-it-when-we-were-out-283/
Votes on record: 285 believed · 53 unsure · 50 didn't · 73% of readers believe this story