The Apartment Had a Door That Was Not on the Floor Plan
73% BELIEVED
CASE FILE #284
FILED: Apr 22, 2026
CLASSIFICATION: Rental Nightmares Stories
WITNESS ON RECORD: WestbournePorter
JURY OF 394 READERS HEARD THIS CASE: 288 believed it, 55 had doubts, 51 weren't buying it.
The apartment was a great deal, a little too great, in a converted old building full of odd angles. There was one locked door in the hallway, plain, painted over at the edges, that did not appear on the floor plan the agency gave us. When we asked, the landlord said it was just an old utility closet, nothing in it, and that he did not even have a key anymore, and not to worry about it. We worried about it a little, then forgot about it, the way you do.
For months we had the feeling of being not quite alone. Sounds in the walls we blamed on old plumbing. The sense, now and then, of being watched in the bedroom, which we put down to nerves in an unfamiliar place. A faint draft from the locked door some nights, and once, twice, a sound from behind it that we told ourselves was the building settling.
When we finally moved out, the landlord was slow to return, and my partner, curious and a little angry about the deposit, worked the painted-over door open with a screwdriver, because at that point what did it matter. It was not a utility closet. Behind it was a narrow space and a set of steep hidden stairs going up into the dead space between our apartment and the one above, the wall thickness we had never questioned.
For months we had the feeling of being not quite alone. Sounds in the walls we blamed on old plumbing. The sense, now and then, of being watched in the bedroom, which we put down to nerves in an unfamiliar place. A faint draft from the locked door some nights, and once, twice, a sound from behind it that we told ourselves was the building settling.
When we finally moved out, the landlord was slow to return, and my partner, curious and a little angry about the deposit, worked the painted-over door open with a screwdriver, because at that point what did it matter. It was not a utility closet. Behind it was a narrow space and a set of steep hidden stairs going up into the dead space between our apartment and the one above, the wall thickness we had never questioned.
THIS EXCERPT ENDS HERE. The remaining 163 words of the testimony — and the reader jury — are on file at:
Read the full case & cast your verdict
https://www.swearithappened.com/rental-nightmare-stories/the-apartment-had-a-door-that-was-not-on-the-floor-plan-284/
Votes on record: 288 believed · 55 unsure · 51 didn't · 73% of readers believe this story