Weekly Case Files: Creepy True Stories on Trial

Every week one story goes on the file: the one readers argued about hardest. These are creepy true stories with a divided verdict — the jury split, the author came back with an epilogue, and you get to see how wrong (or right) everyone was. New file every Monday.

Case File 2026-30: The Woman Using My Name

by LindenVera · jury stood 32 True vs 1 Fake

Case File 2026-29: The Welcome Book Had a Page About Us

by leobro · jury stood 33 True vs 11 Fake

New Stories

Top True By Votes

Random Stories